The Three-Body Problem: Dark Forest - Liu Cixin
2007
“Somewhat earlier, in the dead of night, Mike Evans was standing on the bow of Judgment Day as the Pacific Ocean slipped past like a swath of satin beneath the heavens. Evans enjoyed talking with the distant world at times like these because the text the sophon displayed on his retinas stood out wonderfully against the night sea and sky.
This is our twenty-second real-time conversation. We have come across some difficulties in our communication.
“Yes, Lord. I’ve learned that you can’t actually understand a significant amount of the reference materials on humanity we’ve given you.”
Yes. You’ve explained the parts very clearly, but we are unable to understand the whole. Something is different.
“Just one thing?”
Yes. But it sometimes seems as if your world is missing something, other times that it has something extra, and we don’t know which.
“What is the area of confusion?”
“We’ve carefully studied your documents and have discovered that the key to understanding the problem lies in a pair of synonyms.
“Synonyms?”
There are many synonyms and near-synonyms in your languages. In the first language we received from you, Chinese, there were words that expressed the same meaning, like “cold” and “chill,” “heavy” and “weighty,” “long” and “far.”
“What pair of synonyms created the obstacle to understanding you’ve just mentioned?”
“Think” and “say.” We’ve just learned, to our surprise, that they are not, in fact, synonyms.
“They are not synonyms at all.”
In our understanding, they ought to be. “Think” means using thought organs to conduct mental activity. “Say” means communicating the content of thoughts to a counterpart. The latter, in your world, is accomplished through the modulation of vibrations in the air produced by the vocal cords. Are these definitions correct?”
“They are. But doesn’t this demonstrate that ‘think’ and ‘say’ aren’t synonyms?”
In our understanding, this shows that they are synonyms.
“May I think about this for a moment?”
Very well. We both need to think about it.
For two minutes, Evans gazed in thought at the waves undulating beneath the starlight.
“My Lord, what are your organs of communication?”
We do not have organs of communication. Our brains can display our thoughts to the outside world, thereby achieving communication.
“Display thoughts? How is that done?”
The thoughts in our brains emit electromagnetic waves on all frequencies, including what is visible light to us. They can be displayed at a significant distance.
“So that means that to you, thinking is speaking?”
Hence they are synonyms.
“Oh … That is not the case for us, but even so, that shouldn’t present an obstacle to understanding those documents.”
True. In the areas of thought and communication, the differences between us are not large. We both have brains, and our brains produce intelligence through huge numbers of neural connections. The only difference is that our brain waves are stronger and can be directly received by our counterparts, eliminating the need for communication organs. That’s the only difference.”
“No. I suspect a major difference might be getting lost. My Lord, let me think about it again.”

Last updated